Every rating starts with real 2025/26 match data, converted to per-90 numbers so playing time doesn't skew the result. Each stat is scored against what a Premier League player in that position should be producing, then scaled to a score out of 10.

On top of that sits a fan opinion layer. Stats can't see a defender organising the back four or a striker dragging centre-backs out of position. So the model is tuned by someone who watches every game. The stats lead, the eye test keeps them honest.

Raw numbers are grouped into categories tailored to each position. A goalkeeper is judged on shot stopping and distribution. A winger on goal threat, creativity and carrying. Every position has its own set of categories, and within each one the important stats are weighted higher.

Each bar below is a category score out of 10. Colours shift based on strength.

Category scores feed into a Performance score. A separate Selection score rewards availability based on minutes and appearances. The final Season Rating blends the two, with Performance carrying most of the weight.

Players who have played regularly in more than one position get a breakdown for each role. The Overall Season Rating at the top of the page blends those roles weighted by time spent in each.

• Green (7.5+): excellent.
• Yellow (6.5 to 7.4): good level.
• Orange (5.5 to 6.4): below standard.
• Red (under 5.5): poor return.

• Stats can't capture everything. Leadership, positioning and decoy runs don't always show in the data.
• Small sample sizes can swing early-season numbers. Ratings settle as the season goes on.
• This is a fan project, not an official Everton FC source. See the disclaimer for more.